Superb article on Greek military spending

An absolutely fascinating article from the Guardian by Paul Haydon on Greek military spending, that deserves, and needs, to be circulated far and wide. I had no idea that the Greeks were spending (and are continuing to spend) such a huge portion of their national wealth on arms. It’s truly shocking that the scale of the outlay is so colossal. As the writer points out, it’s a subject that isn’t discussed at all, ever. Why aren’t swingeing cuts in the arms budget the first priority of any austerity programme? That they aren’t highlights graphically the political nature of the cuts being imposed across the EU.

It also casts the moralising of Merkel on the situation the Greeks find themselves enduring in an even less favourable light. The arms deals she has purportedly pressured the Greeks into have further impoverished the country and made the need for German/EU assistance even greater. One can hardly preach fiscal responsibility and attack others in neighbouring states for not having it when one’s policy is to force one’s neighbours to spend money they don’t have, can one?

The sheer hypocrisy of it all stinks, and is something to bear in mind next time you hear a German or French (or British for that matter) government official berate the Greeks for their years of profligacy.  

Paul Haydon’s blog is well worth a look by the way, I don’t agree with all of his politics but he’s an excellent writer. There is a slightly different version of the Guardian article on there and lots of other interesting pieces.


Greece’s austerity doesn’t extend to its arms budget

Greece continues to spend the most on arms in the EU as a percentage of GDP, while its people suffer economic hardship

In the wake of the private sector debt swap agreed last week, European leaders have continued to call for major structural reforms to Greece’s economy and society. The current EU-IMF bailout remains conditional on further austerity measures, including reducing pensions, the minimum-wage and civil service jobs. However, one area of the Greek budget doesn’t seem to have received much scrutiny: its huge military spending.

The fact that Greece, a relatively small and democratic country with not much in the way of global ambitions, should spend as much on its military as it does is perplexing. In 2006, as the financial crisis was looming, Greece was the third biggest arms importer after China and India. And over the past 10 years its military budget has stood at an average of 4% of GDP, more than £900 per person. If Greece is in need of structural reform, then its oversized military would seem the most logical place to start. In fact, if it had only spent the EU average of 1.7% over the last 20 years, it would have saved a total of 52% of its GDP – meaning instead of being completely bankrupt it would be among the more typical countries struggling with the recession.

The supposed threat from Turkey is often cited as the major reason for such a high military budget. However, this argument just doesn’t hold up for several reasons. First, both countries are part of Nato and share a number of mutual allies, not least the US, and so all-out war between the two is highly unlikely to occur. Second, Turkey has on several occasions proposed a mutual reduction in arms spending, something Greece has repeatedly refused to agree to. Finally, relations between the two countries have markedly improved in recent years, making such a massive military build-up seem even more unnecessary. All Greece’s military spending seems to achieve is to polarise the situation and goad Turkey into an arms race.

The second justification given by the Greek government, that its forces are responsible for defending its porous borders from illegal immigration, is only marginally more convincing. While this might account for some increases in spending, it is unclear what role the latest fighter jets, submarines and tanks could play in stemming the tide of migrants arriving by foot or in small boats. So why has Greece continued to spend such huge amounts on its army?

One major factor is that France and Germany’s arms industries have greatly profited from this profligate military spending, leading their governments to put pressure on Greece not to cancel lucrative arms deals. In the five years up to 2010, Greece purchased more of Germany’s arms exports than any other country, buying 15% of its weapons. Over the same period, Greece was the third-largest customer for France’s military exports and its top buyer in Europe. Significantly, when the first bail-out package was being negotiated in 2010, Greece spent 7.1bn euros (£5.9bn) on its military, up from 6.24bn euros in 2007. A total of £1bn was spent on French and German weapons, plunging the country even further into debt in the same year that social spending was cut by 1.8bn euros. It has claimed by some that this was no coincidence, and that the EU bail-out was explicitly tied to burgeoning arms deals. In particular, there is alleged to have been concerted pressure from France to buy several stealth frigates. Meanwhile Germany sold 223 howitzers and completed a controversial deal on faulty submarines, leading to an investigation into accusations of bribes being given to Greek officials.

Admittedly Greek military spending has been significantly reduced over the last year or two, although not nearly as much as government expenditure on healthcare or social welfare. Nonetheless, Greece continues to spend the most in the EU as a percentage of GDP and remains one of the biggest weapons importers in the world. Recent months have also seen continued pressure from Merkel and Sarkozy on Greece to honour its arms deals amid ongoing negotiations over the current bailout deal.

The importance of the global arms trade was highlighted in a recent report showing that sales have increased by a quarter in the last four years, driven by growing demand in Asia. Amid economic stagnation in Europe and the west, military technology remains one of the key areas in which competitive advantage has been maintained over emerging economies. However, while this growth has benefited major arms-exporting countries such as Germany, France and the UK, it has deepened even further the economic divide within Europe. Interestingly, Portugal – another country currently in the news for its economic woes – is Germany’s second largest arms buyer after Greece.

In the current context, it is easy to blame all Greece’s troubles on its problems with corruption, tax evasion and its oversized state sector. Yet one cannot help but speculate that if Greece’s military spending had been reined in sooner, it would not be experiencing the dramatic crisis it is going through now. And the Greek people, instead of facing austerity measures that have reduced living standards by 30%, might have been able to take a more moderate and sustainable route to reform.

1 Comment (+add yours?)

    Mar 24, 2012 @ 23:40:45

    The journalist who wrote this article does not appear to know much about Greece and the security problems of the country. I am a Greek defence analyst and I can emphasize the fact the Greek defence budget has been reduced since 2008 by 37%. The last defence procurement took place on 2008 and the majority of the money spent for procurement is used for the payment of previous orders that took place before 2008. The recent deal for the German submarines was done because there were some serious problems with the 2002 order and the two sides had to renegotiate the deal. As part of the new deal the Germans agreed not to modernize two old submarines but to built two new ones. The problem for the Greek government is that they had paid the Germans in advance. Therefore they had to renegotiate the deal and change the final scheme of the projects. Now regarding the Greek Turkish relations today 24th of March a Turkish frigate sailed with all its weapons systems on few miles from Athens a day before the Independence Day for Greece. Turkey dies not recognize Greek sovereignty on a number of habituated islands in the Aegean sea and recently Turkish fighter jets and helicopters overfly Greek islands with high speed scarring the people of these islands. Not to mention that the Turkish Government still has in effect a law that passed in 1995 according to which if Greece expands its territorial waters from 6 to 12 nm as the international law says Turkey will declare war to Greece. Do you know many countries in Europe that they have to deal with a situation like this?
    You can Read the following articles if you do not believe me
    Some Action see Video

    Wikileaks about Greece Turkey and the Aegean Sea


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: