Another interesting post from Birmingham Against the Cuts. In the city this week one of the big stories has been the prospect of savage cuts in council tax benefit, money that right now the Labour council is discussing how to save. None of the solutions appear very good, and all will end up hurting those with the least the hardest, with possible £200 rises for people quite possibly simply unable to afford such an increase. No change there then from a government happy to introduce tax cuts for the rich but cut services for the most desperate to the bone.

It’s a worrying story, and it’s worthy of note examining the way that the local paper (which has a track record of being pretty right-wing) has spun it. Whilst the story details the actual facts of the situation, the headline and presentation is a little misleading: COUNCIL TAX BOMBSHELL FOR CITY POOR. Now at first glance at this would suggest that the council was of their own accord planning a huge council tax hike. That isn’t the case and I think it’s a poor way to present it, and I worry that the decision was a deliberate one.

The local Labour Party, that has introduced a few tentatively progressive policies like the Living Wage, is clearly in a bind. I’m guessing that they are deeply uncomfortable having to do this as they know the effect this policy will have. It’s a cynical, cowardly move by the government to pass responsibility for the implementation of this cruel, vindictive and unnecessary policy on to local authorities, and as luck would have it in Birmingham we have a newly elected Labour Council that will get the blame instead.

But Labour still plan to implement it one way or another and in the final analysis that is all that really matters. They will say they have no choice but I disagree. This must be opposed and my one criticism of the article I’m re-blogging is that a strategy isn’t laid out to try and stop this. Complaining loudly and waiting for an incoming Labour government to reverse this isn’t good enough (in the first instance there is no guarantee they would anyway…..)

It appears that councils up and down the country are all going to be in the same position. So the (Labour, but I suppose anyone else willing to join them…..) councils should stand together, organise a mass grassroots campaign against this and defy the government. Labour councillors have a democratic mandate and I’m sure none of them were voted in to introduce these types of policies. We have seen previously that the government does buckle under pressure. If the Labour councillors are good little boys and girls and dutifully rubberstamp this then one can guarantee that nothing will change. But if they take a stand, then who knows?

Now of course I’m not seriously expecting this to happen, but I simply don’t accept that the willingness of many Labour councils and councillors to implement the cuts and privatizations demanded of them by the centre is the way forward. It means changing generations of thinking and considering again the importance of bottom-up campaigning of extremely dubious legality. So be it.

Birmingham Against The Cuts

Birmingham City Council yesterday said that due to cuts in central government funding for council tax benefit, it would have to find nearly £12m. Their preferred proposal for this would be to make claimants pay 20% of the council tax due on their property except disabled people and families with children under the age of 6. The ConDem coalition have already said that pensioners cannot have their council tax benefit cut.

This means that anyone who is unemployed or in low paid work will have to find £224 / year on an average property from April 2013. This will raise the £12m necessary to cover the shortfall. Unfortunately, the cuts are being implemented (and hidden) as part of a change to council tax benefit, localising the handling of payments. This new system will cost Birmingham City Council an additional £15m to administer, which wipes out any savings…

View original post 438 more words

1 Comment (+add yours?)

  1. Robert
    Jul 23, 2012 @ 09:44:49

    Then do as we do in Wales and keep on increasing the council tax just above inflation, the simple fact you have to do more and you have to collect more you cannot just sit and say we have been told a four year freeze.

    Labour as a party died a death a long time again, looks at Blair now apologising for the economy, he really is out to make more money using the labour party, Miliband is a mouse and a mouse about to be squashed.

    But if your trying to keep a city going a four year freeze on Tax is not going to work is it


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: